So WTF Is the internet?
Iāve been thinking about the idea of social and tech news sites lately, and noticing that Iām not having a great time with some of them. But that begs the question, āWhat is it that I ever liked about them?ā
What I used to look at
It should be understood that what I used to look for in tech news came from sites that still have zombified versions of themselves online today. There may still be good things about a few of them, but Iāve given up on them for one reason or another.
I think a lot of this started back on a site called Kuro5hin. Gather round, children, Iāll tell you a riddal. Not really, but if you get the reference then make sure youāve taken your medications today. Kuro5hin was an interesting mix of personal blog, forum, proto-Twitter, proto-Reddit, and many other things. The community was vibrant. I was immature enough not to understand how great we had it on the internet in those days. But either way, it was an early āsocial networkā of tech folks. An excellent memory. It existed between 1999 and 2013, but I probably only frequented it between 2001 and 2004. As it was the precursor to things like Digg and Reddit, those new sites are probably where and when my attention wandered away from Kuro5hin. It was an example of excellent community. We do still have that in small pockets of the internet.
Slashdot also qualifies in these early times in much the same way, but more focused on tech/programming. Iām unsure why exactly Slashdot died for me, but I really havenāt been back. Maybe itās worth a check to get a pulse. I recall a redesign mostly turning me off. The best part about Slashdot was certainly that the news was all actually tech focused, and serviced both highly technical topics and general interest tech.
Lifehacker is another great example of a memorable site that lost its sheen. Iām having a hard time tracking it down, but I think probably pre-2010. This was a great place for what Iāll call light advertisement articles that have since become heavy advertisement. Lifehackerās original purpose was great though. What can I do to improve how I interact with tech? What can I do to take better notes? What cool stuff exists to make my life better? Fantastic, when I felt that I could trust it.
That brings us to Reddit and Digg. I was a very early adopter of Reddit. My account, as of this writing, is 15 years old. I think itās technically possible to be 16 years old at various times of the year, but the siteās founder currently shows a 15 year old account. We were playing on Reddit when it didnāt have subreddits. I played on Digg while it didnāt have topics and Kevin Rose was playing on his new creation with us. This is all prehistory at this point. I have always liked the idea of these sites because users can bring their interests, and I can generally hone in on āthe good partsā and ignore whatever Iām not interested in. Thatās not really the case anymore with Reddit, but there are a few hobby areas that arenāt bad. 2016 ruined the site, as far as Iām concerned. We went from a jolly place to find peopleās interests, news, and chat to a place that was increasingly led by external interests. Todayās Reddit is unrecognizable and completely against the spirit of what we were doing in the early days.
What I donāt really need
These days, Iāve noticed that I canāt load any mainstream tech site without seeing keywords about the current governmental powers, one of the richest people in the worldās daily activities, whatever way evil people are working to erode our quality of life via social values, or advertisements so thinly veiled that they should probably be illegal. There is occasionally something interesting sprinkled in, but itās getting hard to justify any āmainstreamā site that I know of.
I donāt want to know about whatever is going on with Space Karen or their enterprises. None of them interest me in the slightest for one reason or another at this point. The reason is mostly Karen, but each has its own nuance. SpaceX removes funding and interest from science/NASA. Tesla makes boring jellybean economy cars sold for too much money, and one extremely ugly virtue signaler. Twitter was already a dumpster fire, so thatās a non-issue. The rest just arenāt interesting to begin with.
I donāt really need to hear about AI until one of a few possible eventualities is realized. First, maybe we do see AGI in our lifetime and itās a thing that can be interacted with. If so, then Iād be interested. I donāt care about the hype train until the point that it is a real and ātangibleā technology. The other option is when the AI hype bubble bursts as it has in the past. At that point, lots of interesting things will have to happen with industry movements, skillsets to train, and whatever assets fall out of the bust. If you ask me on a random day, Iāll tell you that the bust is more likely.
General politics can fuck right off too. Get that shit outta my tech news.
Did you notice that all of the things in this section are basically the same thing. The current social world really has raced to the bottom in terms of variety in a lot of ways. This entire note might as well be about a different existential crisis that we all share whether or not everybody has noticed it yet.
Where Iām hanging out right now and what Iād like to see
The obvious solution to these problems is to find indie/small web āreplacementsā for the corporate machinations that have taken over the internet. I do have some of those, and Iām working to direct more of my intake not just to indie web, but indie web that is dedicated to staying independent. This is an important complication that cannot necessarily be predicted easily. Many things I used to enjoy either died or were acquired and became zombies.
One of the more important things to replace is Reddit. There are a few options that popped up in the wake of app-mageddon, but most of them are the same problem only distributed. Lemmy and kbin are just too similar to their inspiration to be usable for me. The site that has made a difference there is Tildes. This is basically the same initial idea of Reddit, but with limited sub-communities that are easy to filter. The potential downside is that it is not very active, so finding people interested in some particular topic may not happen. In addition, you canāt really doomscroll it. Thatās probably a good thing, but letās be honest about motivations for using sites like this: time wasting.
Mastodon has also taken up residence in a very real way. I scroll my local instance, social.lol, run by the most excellent omg.lol. Iāve found mostly good like-minded folks, topics I am interested in, and very few of the things that make me sad. When I do find a sad thing, itās easy to add a filter to get rid of it. I think this is an important key in mental health on the modern web.
I want to note one small detail about like-minded folks and spaces. Iām not building an echo chamber. I am simply not interested in giving my time and attention to objectively terrible people. If you donāt pass the smell check, I donāt need you. Simple as that. Believe it or not, thereās lots of room for discussion and disagreement amongst those of us who adhere to reasonable social standards. If thatās radical to you, I think you should evaluate your behavior. omg.lolās People Principles are a pretty good start to such a philosophy.
The downside to the previous two examples of things I visit is that there just isnāt as much activity on these corners of the web. Itās not always possible to see the latest about particular interests if youāre looking where the people that discuss those topics arenāt hanging out. So unfortunately, I still havenāt completely replaced the corporate internet.
Pockets of Reddit are still useful and interesting. Hobby reddits are vibrant areas that I would be putting myself at a disservice if I ignore. Drama happens in these places that matters and affects the tools I use both in hobbies and in professional settings. A recent example of that is the 3D printing community pushing back on Bambu Lab's terrible ecosystem changes. These things do matter, so I canāt just ignore them.
In addition, there are still regular tech sites that I look at. The trick Iāve come across is that Iāve mostly concentrated on getting their posts from Mastodon, where thereās already a filter in the way. So I still visit Ars Tchenica, TechCrunch, The Verge, and many other sources that I find to be less than wholesome in their modern form. I would love to be able to ignore them, but itās not reasonable just as with Reddit.
Hopefully someday Iāll find myself in a world that is cushioned from the mind games that we play on one another. Until then, these are my current solutions. If you would like to get started with Tildes or omg.lol, please Toot at me: @[email protected].
Posted on 2025-01-25 by u/cws